Journal of Spanish, Portuguese, and Italian Crypto-Jews (JOSPIC-J)
  • Welcome
  • Table of Contents
  • Editorial
  • Submissions
  • Subscriptions
  • Sponsors
  • Major Issues
  • Jewish DNA
  • People
  • Links

One of the major issues concerning research on Crypto-Jews is the exact term which should be used. Is it Marrano, Converso, Crypto Jew, Secret Jew, Hidden Jew, New Christian, or Anusim? The following article, from Volume 3, Spring 2011, pages 150-155, discusses this issue.


Dr. Abraham D. Lavender
Editor in Chief, JOSPIC-J


In Volume 1 (2009) of this journal, it was noted that one of the major issues facing the growing academic study of “crypto Jews” is which term to use to describe the Jews in Spain, Portugal, or Italy who converted, or pretended to convert, to Christianity in the time of the Inquisition. An analysis of 118 books which included, in the title or subtitle, one or more of seven terms, was included. This is an update, analyzing 134 books (146 words) including some new listings and some not listed in 2009. This list is extensive, but not complete, and more listings are welcomed. Following are changes in the seven terms since 1925, in three time periods. There also has been a large increase in the number of books by decade; 1920s, 2; 1930s, 4; 1940s, 5; 1950s, 1; 1960s, 4; 1970s, 13; 1980s, 22; 1990s, 31; 2000s, 49; 2010s so far, 3. The continuous increase began in the 1970s.

In the early period, Marrano was the most used term, and Converso was second. In the middle period, Converso strongly passed Marrano to become the most used term. Since 2000, Converso has decreased, but still remains a strong first, and Crypto Jew has narrowly passed Marrano to become second. New Christian ranked a distant third in the early period, but has decreased since then. Secret Jew and especially Hidden Jew are seldom used. Anusim is still rarely used in books, although it is increasingly being used in articles.

1925-1939 (6 books, 7 words)


Os Cristaos-Novos em Portugal No Seculo XX
, 1925, Samuel Schwartz

Report on the Marranos or Crypto-Jews of Portugal
: Presented to the Alliance Israelite Universelle and the Council of the Anglo-Jewish Association, 1926, Lucian Wofle

A History of the Marranos
, 1932, Cecil Roth

Die Marranen in Der Rabbinischen Literatur
, 1932, H.J. Zimmels

History of the Jews, From the Rise of Kabbala to the Permanent Settlement of the Marranos in Holland 1618 C.E., 1933
, Heinrich. Graetz

Marranos and Other Poems
, 1935, Abraham Morganstern

1940-1969 (10 books, 10 words)
 

New Marranos: A Play in Seven Scenes
, 1940, Samuel J. Citron

Los Marranos, Un Intento de Definicion
, 1946, Boleslao Lewin

Samuel Usque: Marrano Historian of the Sixteenth Century
, 1946, Abraham A. Newman

Hispano-Arabic Marrano and its Hispano-Latin Homophone
, 1948, Yakov Malkiel

Ha-Anusim: A Story From the Days of the Spanish Inquisition
, 1940s, Meir Mitchell (in Hebrew)

Alvar Garcia de Santa Maria: Historia de la Juderia de Burgos y de Sus Conversos Mas Egregios
, 1952, Francisco Cantera Burgos

The Chosen One: A Novel of the Marranos in Portugal and the Inquisition
, 1964, Harry Simonoff

The Marranos of Spain: From the Late 14th to the Early 16th Century
, 1966, Benjamin Netanyahu

Marrano-Jewish Entrepreneurship and the Ottoman Mercantilist Probe in the Sixteenth Century
, 1967, Ellis Rivkin

The Records of the Inquisition: A Source of Jewish and Converso History (Proceedings of the Israel Academy of Sciences and Humanities
, 1967, Haim Beinart

1970-1979 (13 books, 13 words)


Os Cripto-Judeus
, 1970, Amilcar Paulo

Os Marranos em Portugal: Reminiscencias Judio-Portuguesas
, 1971, Amilcar Paulo

Cristaos Novos na Bahia
, 1972, Anita Novinsky

The Chuetas of Marjorca: Conversos and the Inquisition of Majorca
, 1972, Baruch Braunstein

The Converso Community in 15th – 17th Century Spain
, 1972, Haim Beinart

The Martyr: Luis de Carvajal, a Secret Jew in Sixteenth Century Mexico
, 1973, Martin A. Cohen

The Secret Jews
, 1973, Joachim Prinz

How Jewish Were the Marranos
, 1973, Ellis Rivkin

History of Anti-Semitism: From Mahommed to the Marranos
, 1974, Leon Poliakov

The De Pinto Manuscript: A 17th Century Marrano Family History
, 1975, H.P. Salomon

Los Origenes del Problema Converso
, 1976, Eloy Benito Ruano

Marrano
, 1976, Martin H. Ross

The Mirror of the New Christians
, 1977, Francisco Machado, Frank E.Talmadge, and Mildred E. Vieira

1980-1989 (22 books, 23 words)


The Re-education of Marranos in the Seventeenth Century
, 1980, Yosef Hayim Yerushalmi

Conversos on Trial: The Inquisition in Ciudad Real
, 1981, Haim Beinart

Marranos
, 1981, Liliane Webb

Marrano Ibero-Romance: Classification and Research Tasks
, 1982, Paul Wexler

Marrano Poets of the Seventeenth Century
, 1982, Timothy Oelman

Sobre Judios, Moriscos y Conversos: Convivencia y Ruptura de la Trescastas
, 1982, Jose Jimenez Lozano

Los Conversos Ante el Tribunal de la Inquisicion
, 1983, Haim Beinart

Sobre Arabes, Judios y Marranos y su Impacto en la Lengua y Literatura Espanolas
, 1983, Joseph M. Sol Sole

El Xueta, o, Les Set Vides d’un Descendant de Jueus Conversos
, 1984, M. Ferra I Martorell

Jews and Conversos: Studies in Society and the Inquisition
, 1985, Yosef Kaplan

Las Conversos: Pieza Teatral en dos Pares
, 1985, Solly Wolodarsky

Os Judeus Secretos
, 1985, Amilar Paulo

The Conversos of Majorca: Life and Death in a Crypto-Jewish Community in 17th Century Spain
, 1986, Angela S. Selke

La Inquisicion en Andalucia: Resistencia de Los Conversos a su Implantacion
, 1986, Antonio Cascales Ramos

Gaspar da Gama: Un Converso na Frota de Cabral
, 1987, E. Lipiner

Roots and Boots: From Crypto-Jew in New Spain to Community Leader in the American Southwest
, 1987, Floyd S. Fierman

Conversos and the Inquisition in Jaen
, 1988, Luis Coronos Tejada

El Auto de Fe de 1593: Los Conversos Granadinos de Origen Judio
, 1988, Maria Antonia Bel Bravo

The Marrano Prince
, 1988, Avner Gold

The Marrano: Poems
, 1988, Barry Goldensohn and Douglas Kinsey

Ya Converso Mas
, 1989

Spinoza and Other Heretics: The Marranos of Reason
(Volume 1),

1989, Yirmiyahi Yovel

1990-1999 (31 books, 32 words)


The Last Crypto-Jews of Portugal
, 1990, David Augusto Canelo

Judio Conversos: Los Antepasados Judios de las Familias Tradicionales Argentinas
, 1990, Mario Javier Saban

La Clase Social de Los Conversos in Castilla en la Edad Moderna
, 1991, Antonio Dominguez Ortiz

Ben-Anusim
, 1991, Avi Katz, Orit Uziel

In the Shadow of History: Jews and Conversos at the Dawn of Modernity
, 1992, Jose Faur

Los Marranos en el Paraguay Colonial
, 1992, Clara E. Cohan

The Marranos: A Novel
, 1992, Howard Rose

Columbus, Marrano Discoverer from Mallorca: In Honor of the 500th Anniversary of the Discovery of America by Columbus
, 1992, Martin Sable

La Fine del Giudaismo Siciliano: Ebrei Marrani e Inquisizione Spagnold Prima, Durante e Dopo la Cacciata del 1492
, 1993, Francesco Renda

El Siddur en Catala dels Conversos Jueus: Conservat a la Reial Academia
, 1993, Jaume Riera i Sans

Marranos y la Economia en El Rio de la Plata, 1993, Mario J. Saban

The Mezuzah in the Madonna’s Foot: Marranos and Other Secret Jews
, 1994, Trudi Alexy

Trujillo-Indias, Una Ruta de Conversos
, 1994, Alicia Gojman de Backal

Inquisicion y Conversos: Conferencias Pronunciadas en el III Curso de Cultura Hispano-Judia y Sefardi de la Universidad de Castilla-La Mancha
, 1994, Asociacion de Amigos del Museo Sefardi-Caja e Castilla la Mancha

Los Conversos, Victimas o Victimarios de Espana
, 1994, Federico Rivanera Carles

Judios, Sefarditas, Conversos: La Expulsion de 1492 y Sus Consecuencias
, 1995, Angel Alcala Ambito

Las Raices de la Hidalguia Guipuzcoana: El Control de los Judios, Conversos y Extranjeros en Guipuzcoa Durante el Siglo XVI
, 1995, Jose Luis Orella

Conversos, Inquisition and the Expulsion of the Jews from Spain
, 1995, Norman Roth

 Identidad y Cultura en Conversos del Siglo XVII en Puebla de Los Angeles (Cuadernos de Investigacion), 1995, Alicia G. De Backal

Secrecy and Deceit: The Religion of the Crypto-Jews
, 1996, David Gitlitz

Sephardim of Portland and Seattle Plus Crypto Jews of the American Southwest
, 1996, William Kramer

Marrano as Metaphor: The Jewish Presence in French Writing
, 1996, Elaine Marks

Ben Rosh: Biografia do Capitao Barros Basto, O Apostolo dos Marranos
, 1997, Elvira Azevedo Mea

Maestre Pedro de la Cabra, Medico Converso Aragones del Siglo XV: Autor de unas Coplas de Arte Menor
, 1998, Encarnacion Marin Padilla

Toward the Inquisition: Essays on Jewish and Converso History in Late Medieval Spain
, 1998, Benzion Netanyahnu

A Drizzle of Honey: The Lives and Recipes of Spain’s Secret Jews
, 1999, David M. Gitlitz and Linda Kay Davidson

Hebrews of the Portuguese Nation: Conversos and Community in Early Modern Amsterdam
, 1999, Miriam Bodian

Sobre Jueus I Conversos de les Balears, 1999, Lleonard Muntaner

Portugal’s Secret Jews: The End of an Era
, 1999, Eduardo Mayone Dias

The New Otherness: Marrano Dualities in the First Generation
, 1999, Yirmiyahu Yovel

Heretics or Daughters of Israel? The Crypto-Jewish Women of Castile
, 1999, Renee Levine Melammed

2000-2010 (49 books, 60 words)


Judio y Conversos en la Castilla Medieval
, 2000, Julio Valdeon Baruque

Linajudos and Conversos in Seville: Greed and Prejudice in Sixteenth and Seventeenth Century Spain
, 2000, Ruth Pike

Crypto-Judaism and the Spanish Inquisition
, 2001, Michael Alpert

Troubled Souls: Conversos, Crypto-Jews, and Other Confused Intellectuals From the Fourteenth Through the Eighteenth Century
, 2001, Charles Meyers and Norman T. Simms

The Marrano Factory: The Portuguese Inquisition and its New Christians 1536-1765
, 2001, Jose Saraiva, H.P. Salomon, I.S.D. Sassoon

Marrano
, 2001, P.E. Jeffe

The Conquistodores and Crypto-Jews of Monterrey
, 2001, David T. Raphael

Hidden Heritage: The Legacy of the Crypto-Jews
, 2002, Janet Liebman Jacobs

Incognito: Journey of a Secret Jew
, 2002, Maria Espinosa

Diasporas Within a Diaspora; Jews, Crypto-Jews, and the World of Maritime Empires 1540-1740
, 2002, Jonathan Irvine Israel

Tu Vi Marrano
, 2002, Luciano Ascoli

The Evolution of Converso Literature: The Writings of the Converted Jews of Medieval Spain
, 2002, Gregory B. Kaplan

Converso, ou, La Fuite au Mexique: Roman
, 2002, Michel Host

Souls in Dispute: Converso Identities in Iberia and the Jewish Diaspora, 1580-1700
, 2003, David L. Graizbord

In the Shadow of the Virgin: Inquisitors, Frairs, and “Conversos” in Guadalupe, Spain
, 2003, Gretchen D. Starr-LeBeau

Los Conversos en Espana y Portugal
, 2003, Juan Ignacio Pulido Serrano

A Network of Converso Families in Early Modern Toledo: Assimilating a Minority
, 2003, Linda Martz

The Marrano Legacy: A Contemporary Crypto-Jewish Priest Reveals Secrets of His Double Life
, 2003, Trudi Alexy

La Geste del Marrano
, 2003, Marcos Aquinis

Entre La Cruz y La Hoguera: Sefarditas, Conversos y Anusim
, 2003, Manuel Hernandez Gomez

De Judios a Judeo-Conversos: Reflexiones Sobre El Ser Converso
, 2003, Rica Amran

A Question of Identity: Iberian Conversos in Historical Perspectives
, 2004, Renee Levine Melammed

The Converso Legacy
, 2004, Sheldon Gardner

El Converso
, 2004, Jose Manuel Fajardo Gonzalez

Inquisitional Inquiries: Brief Lives of Secret Jews and Other Heretics
, 2004, Richard L. Kagan and Abigail Dyer

Remnants of Crypto-Jews Among Hispanic Americans
, 2004, Gloria Golden

Crypto-Judaism, Madness, and “the Female Quixote”:Charlotte Lennox as Marrana in Mid-Eighteenth Century England
, 2004, Norman T. Simms

To the End of the Earth: A History of the Crypto-Jews of New Mexico
, 2005, Stanley M. Hordes

Dicionario Sefaradi de Sobrenomes/Dictionary of Sephardic Surnames: Inclusive Cristaos-Novos, Conversos, Marranos, Italianos, Berberes E Sua Historie Na Espanha, Portugal e Italia/Including Christianized Jews, Conversos
, 2005, Guilhemme Faigenboim, Paulo Valadares, and Anna Rosa Compagnano

La Leyenda Negra de Expana y Los Marranos
, 2006, Adolfo Kuznitzky

Converso, 2006, Hazel Arnett

Dying in the Law of Moses: Crypto-Jewish Martyrdom in the Iberian World
, 2007, Miriam Bodian

Barros Basto, the Marrano Mirage: A New Vision of the Life and Work of the Apostle of the Marranos
, 2007, Alexandre Teixeira Mendes

Dictionary of Iberian Jewish and Converso Authors
, 2007, Norman Roth

My Grandmother’s Letters: A Jewish Legacy in the New World Among the Hidden Jews of New Mexico
, 2007, Charlene Mitchell Gallegos Neely

Um Morgada de Miserias: O Auto de Um Poeta Marrano
, 2007, Benair Alcaraz Fernandes Ribeiro

Marrano
, 2007, P.E. Jeffe

Judios Conversos: La Influencia Hebrea en los Origenes de las Familias Tradicionales Argentinas
, 2007, Mario Javier Saban

Carcao, A Capital do Marranismo
, 2008, Maria Fernanda Guirmaraes and Julio Andrade

Brotherhood of the Light: A Novel About the Penitentes and the Crypto-Jews of New Mexico
, 2008, Ray Michael Baca

Atlantic Diasporas: Jews, Conversos, and Crypto-Jews in the Age of Mercantilism 1500-1800
, 2008, Richard L. Kagan and Philip D. Morgan

New Mexico’s Crypto-Jews: Image and Memory
, 2008, Cary Herz, Ori Z. Soltes, and Mona Hernandez

Conversos of the Americas
, 2008, Keith Fogel and Marlan E. Fogel

Guglielmo Raimondo Moncada Alias Flavio Mitridate: Un Ebreo Converso Siciliano
, 2008, Luciana Pepi, Maauro Perani

Marranos on the Maradas: Secret Jews and Penitentes in the Southwestern United States
, 2009, Norman T. Simms

The Other Within, the Marranos: Split Identity and Emerging Modernity
, 2009, Yirmiyahu Yovel

Juggling Identities: Identity and Authenticity Among the Crypto-Jews
, 2009, Seth D. Kunin

Converso
, 2009, Mario X. Martinez

Portuguese Jewry at the Stake: Studies on Jews and Crypto Jews
, 2009, Yom Tov Assis and Moises Orfali (eds). (in Hebrew)

2010-present (3 books, 3 words)


La Alianza del Converso
, 2010, Augustin Bernaldo Palatchi

Mexicans of Converso Descent
, 2010 (30 pages), Diego Rivera, Luis de Carabajal y Cueva, Diego de Montemayor, Francisco Guevara, Roberto de La Rocha

Hispanics of Converso Descent
, 2010 (38 pages), Diego Rivera

Endnotes

1. Anusim is a plural term. As Lavender (2009) noted (p. 8), the term is rarely used in English in plural form and even less in singular form (anus or anous), probably because of the similarity to an English word that some readers consider negative. As a Hebrew word, it is used in Israel more than elsewhere. See Abraham D. Lavender, “The Secret Jews of Spain, Portugal, and Italy and Their Descendants Today: Major Issues in a Growing Field of Academic Research,” JOSPIC-J, Volume 1, Spring 2009, pp. 3-16. Since 2000, there is also a small tendency to use two different words, one in the title and another in the subtitle, perhaps reflecting the current ambiguity about the correct word, or the existence of a transition period, or, perhaps, to “play it safe” and get the “biggest bang for the buck.” This is also common in books about African Americans, or Blacks, frequently following this two-word pattern.

Create a free website with Weebly